What if the admin split never happened.

[King Kickass]

Hang on, in this hypothetical situation, did Soul step down from Owner and be replaced by Temar or is he still Owner and no tensions around his position occurred?

It's almost impossible for me to see a situation where Soul steps down even if it's hypothetical but for this case Sure, one where Temar gained full responsibility of the Community. But then again saying that i guess the answer to that is the other community.  I don't know which of the two situations you said would be the better one and also i don't know why the current staff does not have the same issue's with soul that the previous team did.