Punishments

[Legion]

A set of guidelines for something spewing endless possibilities is a guide for failure. You thought the rules were bad, this would be worse and I wouldn't expect anyone to ever follow it.

I don't see why this will be a failure.
When a teacher check tests they have an indicator as well.
I think there should be an indicator for the staff which will tell what is the maximum and minimum time for each punishment. for each rule breakage repetition, it will set a new maximum and minimum. In addition, admins should use their own judgment within the limits of the indicator.

I don't see why two equal players should have different punishment times for the same rule breakage because "admins decide that".

Because every case is different and there’s different circumstances, common sense... Am I right?

Yes thats right but still there shold a limit.
Even in courthouse in real life almost every punishment have a beween time of punishment and the time inside the borders is decided by the judge in every case.
There should be an indicator which will reduce Admin Abuse of deciding the length of ban and help them decide the length.
Anyway I dont see why this is bad for the community, you can always try something new.
Overview is defenitly needed and a change in approach when should you really punish the person.
Ban should always be the last resort.

Dont forget it is only a game and everyone doing a mistake sometimes, even admins.