Is this a valid reason to kill someone? (Costed me a perm ban)

Kurrey

Can I kill a citizen for blocking a door for over 1 minute and punching me when trying to get out? I got perm banned for this.

**DoomDude1**

The reason why your ban is permanent is because it is your 13th ban. You've had enough chances.

James_Gaff

(05-29-2014, 08:24 PM)Doomdude1 Wrote: The reason why your ban is permanent is because it is your 13th ban. You've had enough chances.

Not to be rude but his question remains un-answered. His question is if he can kill someone for punching him after he tried to get out a blocked room.

**DoomDude1**

(05-29-2014, 10:23 PM)Jamester Wrote:
(05-29-2014, 08:24 PM)Doomdude1 Wrote: The reason why your ban is permanent is because it is your 13th ban. You've had enough chances.

Not to be rude but his question remains un-answered. His question is if he can kill someone for punching him after he tried to get out a blocked room.

No, he is to call an online staff member or record and post a ban request.

James_Gaff

This is from a general point of view;

If someone punches you (rp or not) surely you have the right to defend yoursf? Dont get me wrong, maybe kiling is a bit far but none the less... Surely if your life is in potential danger?

**DoomDude1**

(05-29-2014, 10:32 PM)Jamester Wrote: This is from a general point of view;

If someone punches you (rp or not) surely you have the right to defend yoursf? Dont get me wrong, maybe kiling is a bit far but none the less... Surely if your life is in potential danger?

Blocking a door and punching a person who wants to pass through can hardly be called RP.

James_Gaff

(05-29-2014, 10:51 PM)Doomdude1 Wrote:
(05-29-2014, 10:32 PM)Jamester Wrote: This is from a general point of view.

If someone punches you (rp or not) surely you have the right to defend yoursf? Dont get me wrong, maybe kiling is a bit far but none the less... Surely if your life is in potential danger?

Blocking a door and punching a person who wants to pass through can hardly be called RP.

Not what I asked now was it? Also, im trying to be polite but your doging my questions. He is asking if it is right that he killed player x for blocking a door and punching him when he tried to pass.

yarrrs

From a law point of view, being attacked with fists can be considered use of a deadly weapon if the intention to kill was flowing through the attackers head, hence you can Stand Your Ground to neutralize/defuse the situation at hand. Hell, in California the defendant is even allowed to chase down the assailant if it will ultimately neutralize/defuse the situation.

That being said, if he was punching you and not letting you out, you could act as if he was shoving you inside, like a hard push, which is not a reasonable suspicion at that particular moment that your death or bodily injury to yourself will occur.

Baskingner

It is not up to me to decide but it sounds weird to me that he got banned for killing someone who punched him...

For example if player A is in a house RPing and player B walks in and forcing player A to stay inside, punching him when trying to escape. That sounds to me like "holding someone capture". If i had a gun in my room and that was my only "resolution" i would have shot him as well... i dont see why i should bother a staff member with that. Since if explained correctly, it could have been RPed...

@doomdude can you elaborate why it is not allowed to shoot in a situation like this? Since i find it a bit confusing!

~~Jan~~

Your question was answered, Kurrey. No it is not a valid reason, and now you're perma-banned.

Now what's this whole discussing in this thread?